From Global Best Practices to Local Transformation: What Can Pakistan Learn from Developed Countries in Early Childhood Care and Education? A Comparative Narrative Review

Authors

  • Muhammad Rafiq-uz-Zaman Ph.D. in Education, Master Trainer, Punjab Education, Curriculum, Training & Assessment Authority (PECTAA), School Education Department, Bahawalnagar, Punjab, Pakistan. Author https://orcid.org/0009-0002-4853-045X
  • Huma Shah Ph.D. Scholar, Department of Education, Government College University, Faisalabad, Punjab, Pakistan Author
  • Yi-Huang Shih Associate Professor, Center of Teacher Education, Minghsin University of Science and Technology, Hsinchu, Taiwan Author
  • Dr. Ayesha Riaz Associate Professor, Institute of Home Science, University of Agriculture Faisalabad, Pakistan Author

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.69671/socialprism.3.9.2026.343

Keywords:

Early Childhood Care and Education, Comparative Education, Pakistan, Policy Learning, Early Childhood Workforce, Play-Based Pedagogy, Quality Assurance, Equity

Abstract

Background. ECCE integrates care, education, workforce and governance. Comparing national systems can be helpful to inform the reform process, but this could lead to overlooking differences in resources, institutions and social context in the process of borrowing policies. Objective. This is a narrative review to identify what can be learned from ECCE research in Finland, Sweden, Norway, Singapore, Japan and Australia and what adaptations can be made locally. Method. Literature search was performed in the three databases, namely Semantic Scholar, OpenAlex and PubMed on 5 October 2026, through a narrative search including broad search terms related to governance, curriculum, workforce, access, quality, inclusion, Pakistan. Abstracts of and selected accessible full-texts were reviewed. This did not constitute a systematic review. Comparative scope and findings. An analysis of recent evidence from Pakistan finds policy-to-practice gaps and significant differences between school types: A study of 52 public, private and nonprofit schools in Karachi indicates that overall classroom quality is weak, but there is comparatively high quality in interactions; and a stepped-wedge trial in a rural setting in Sindh shows positive results for school readiness from a youth delivered community ECCE program. Local responsibility, play, well-being, and evaluation of learning environments are highlighted in Nordic research, as are variation and ongoing quality issues. The quality of Japanese observations also varies, with care routines and interactions being relatively strong and learning activities being relatively weak. Evidence available for Singapore and Australia was less and was primarily comparable/review type. Conclusion and policy implications. The Pakistanis should borrow functions and not institutional templates: build the capacity of providers at the provincial level, provide support for educators through practice-based development, create play-rich, language-responsive environments, integrate ECCE with family and community services, and observe settings and children's experiences while not compromising quality by testing children. The proposed road map is tentative. This manuscript should not be considered complete or even suitable for publication until such time as official policy and statistical verification has been completed, and access to pre-2021 literature has been gained.

Downloads

Published

19.11.2026

How to Cite

Rafiq-uz-Zaman, M., Shah, H., Shih, Y.-H., & Riaz, D. A. (2026). From Global Best Practices to Local Transformation: What Can Pakistan Learn from Developed Countries in Early Childhood Care and Education? A Comparative Narrative Review. SOCIAL PRISM, 3(9), 411-434. https://doi.org/10.69671/socialprism.3.9.2026.343